'Lot of questions:' Free DNA tests offered after Manitoba men switched at birth

By The Canadian Press
August 30, 2016 - 6:05pm

NORWAY HOUSE, Man. — When Ron Evans was 17, he worked as a driver shuttling staff home after their shifts at the Norway House Indian Hospital in northern Manitoba.

He's now racking his brain trying to think of the names of workers he knew back in 1975, the same year four men were switched at birth at the hospital in the remote community 800 kilometres north of Winnipeg.

"The community, of course, has a lot of questions," says Evans, who is now chief of the Norway House Cree Nation.

"Was it honest mistakes that were made or was it malicious? That's what's going through the minds of many, including mine."

Two men from Norway House announced last week — and two men from nearby Garden Hill revealed last year — that they had been switched at birth at the federally run hospital in 1975.

David Tait Jr. and Leon Swanson cried in front of news cameras Friday after receiving initial DNA test results. Tests last November showed Luke Monias and Norman Barkman also went home from the hospital with each other's families.

The two cases have raised the question of whether there could be more.

Health Canada spokesman Eric Morrissette said Tuesday that the department is offering free DNA tests to anyone born at the Norway House hospital in the mid-1970s. The test costs approximately $750 and involves a cheek swab from the mother and their son or daughter.

He said there were 239 babies born there in 1975. He couldn't say if anyone had requested the free tests yet and wasn't aware of any other cases of babies being switched at birth.

The department has started reviewing the hospital's historical files, said Morrissette, who added an independent third party will soon be tasked to investigate the mix-ups. The results are to be made public.

Evans said it's plausible that a switch might happen if babies are born minutes or hours apart, but Tait and Swanson were born three days apart. "How can they make that kind of mistake?" 

If one person was at fault, he said, it's possible he or she may no longer be alive. Evans can recall the names of some nurses from the '70s, but they have died, he said.

So far, he added, he hasn't heard of any other people who suspect they were switched at birth and want DNA tests, but that could come later.

Morrissette said only emergency births happen at the hospital now, with those being around one every two months. Most pregnant women in the community are sent to Thompson and Winnipeg to give birth.

The policy of putting identification bands on babies immediately after birth began at the Norway House hospital in 1980.

The hospital was also a hub for surrounding communities. Residents of about 15 reserves would have had their babies there, said Grand Chief Sheila North Wilson, who represents northern Manitoba First Nations.

Health Canada notified her Monday about the free DNA tests, she said, and she's been passing on the information to other indigenous leaders. She believes the tests are only being offered for those born in the mid-70s because identification bands were used on babies after that.

She said she asked a health official why they weren't notifying everyone born at the Norway House hospital in the mid-70s about the testing.

"They said they wouldn't want to unnecessarily alarm people in doing that, so they're just going to wait for people to come forward."

She hasn't heard of others who believe they were switched, but said there have been rumours for years that it was happening.

"It wasn't taken seriously because it was just so unbelievable. But I think now people will start to remember those stories and see if there's any truth to them."

— By Chris Purdy in Edmonton

The Canadian Press

©2016 The Canadian Press

Canada Post, union reach tentative deal; averts possible job action this week

Join the Discussion

We are happy to provide a forum for commenting and discussion. Please respect and abide by the house rules: Keep it clean, keep it civil, keep it truthful, stay on topic, be responsible, share your knowledge, and please suggest removal of comments that violate these standards. See full commenting rules.